Back to Newsroom

Op-Ed: Bitly must make its non-reuse promise verifiable

Old Bitly links sent readers to unrelated pages. Nicholas Thomas argues that protecting retired addresses belongs in the service customers buy.

Op-Ed by Nicholas Thomas. The views in this article are the author’s analysis and opinion.

Old links in Burger King and McDonald’s posts sent readers to unrelated pages this weekend, according to separate November 15 reports from Ransomnews and CNN, republished by KESQ. CNN reported that Bitly acknowledged misuse of some old, inactive links, suspended the accounts involved and was disabling affected URLs.

My view: protecting an address after its original campaign ends is part of the product a link-management company sells. Bitly should make its promise that old identifiers cannot be reused something customers can verify.

The obligation outlives the campaign

A short link is a small address that sends the reader onward to another destination. The business putting it in a public message lends that address its reputation. The message can remain available long after the employee, campaign budget or supplier contract has moved on.

That creates an awkward division of responsibility. The brand remains visible to the reader, while a service operates the routing in between. A procurement team should treat the behavior of that address in retirement as a continuing service obligation. A campaign ending does not tell every future reader to stop trusting its links.

Bitly’s account-deletion guidance, updated August 17, already says default bit.ly links continue working and their generated or custom endings cannot be reused. That makes the reported redirects a question about how the promise is enforced. Account deletion has not been established here as the cause of this incident.

I would want a supplier to explain what happens when a customer leaves, when a destination is removed and when a link becomes unsafe. An address could continue to its authorized destination or display a clear retirement notice. Quietly handing the audience to an unrelated destination should fail the acceptance test.

The limits matter

There is a reasonable narrower reading. This may concern a limited group of legacy links, with containment already reducing the problem. Ransomnews reported that the Burger King and McDonald’s links it checked had stopped redirecting by 19:22 UTC on November 15. Its investigation also found recreated links leading to apparently appropriate destinations; it did not establish who recreated those or why.

Those distinctions matter. A changed creation record alone should not become an accusation that every such link was malicious. Nor do the reports establish that all Bitly links are unsafe. The outstanding question is which addresses were exposed and what now prevents unauthorized reuse.

Running your own redirect service would not make this obligation disappear. Someone would still have to maintain it. For many businesses, paying a specialist can be a sensible choice. My objection is to evaluating that purchase solely through the convenience of creating links and measuring clicks, while leaving their eventual retirement out of the decision.

What would change my view

A documented explanation of the affected group, the cause and the enforcement now in place would make a meaningful difference. Independent checks showing that retired identifiers remain unavailable for unrelated reuse would provide stronger reassurance still.

For business buyers, the practical implication is specific: ask for link-retirement behavior, an inventory you can retain and a named incident contact before signing the next contract. Include those answers in the renewal decision. An old address should not acquire a new owner’s purpose simply because the original customer has stopped looking at the dashboard.

Sources checked November 15, 2026, through 9:35 p.m. Eastern (02:35 UTC November 16). Reporting dates are November 15; Bitly’s policy is earlier context. TrendyVest reviewed the linked reports and policy, not the affected redirects firsthand. The full scope and technical cause remain unresolved in the reviewed evidence.

More from the Newsroom